A man who wore his wife’s clothes in secret also obviously harboured a closeted homosexuality. I don’t think it could possibly succeed at drawing out its social questions if it failed to present well-described human characters in largely believable55Not being Japanese, I don’t really have any sense of how much verisimilitude with which Takako represents the Japanese reaction toward transvestitism and transgenderism and transsexualism. MyAnimeList.net is a property of MyAnimeList Co.,Ltd. Takako employs a simple illustration style that provokes the reader to focus on characters, their expressions, and the way they carry themselves. In a year of some fantastic books, Wandering Son continues to shine and is easily recommendable. Fifteen years later he is still proud of that decision. In this final volume, we see them and all of the people around them for the last time. Notice at Collection Find helpful customer reviews and review ratings for Wandering Son [7] at Amazon.com. Synopsis: “The fifth grade. In a gathering of high school kids for some event or other, there was a game in which people would have to perform some stunt of the leader’s choosing. The most important is that this series decided to try and look at the issue seriously. Maho and Shuichi begin to model. Based on: The Hourou Musuko manga by Takako Shimura Length: The show is made up of a single 12 episode season, with the story beginning … Review by Rebecca Silverman, Nov 17th 2012. We needed to meet all of the characters in order to understand whose young lives we will be following on our journey into youth psychology. Article first published as Manga Review: Wandering Son Volume Two by Shimura Takako on Blogcritics.. Wandering Son Volume Two is a manga by Shimura Takako, and it was published in North America by Fantagraphics Books in 2012. Review. Both clearly demonstrate the challenges of having binary sex system or the society's practice of heterosexuality. Good Ok Bad :: Reviews of Comic Books, Graphic Novels, Manga, and Comics, Which should be easy, right? The art is rather lovely, the lines fine and bold. In a show of friendship, Yoshino confesses a … Mar 16, 2015 - This Pin was discovered by virginia fernández. Sitemap. Wandering Son is a series which looks at the implications of these and other ideas by taking a peek into the life of a middle school student: The feminine boy, Nitori, who privately cross-dresses and begins to identify as a girl. (Request an anime for review here.) On top of that, Nitorin is dealing with a school system that shames "his" behavior and has "him" sent home for wearing a girl's uniform (although female characters wearing a boy's uniform are not). They aren’t cartooned caricatures of pedagogical lances meant to joust with our presuppositions. Really, we shouldn’t even need a book to make the effort, but even my own very narrow personal history demonstrates with force that we do need books to make the effort. Press Room Privacy Settings Read honest and unbiased product reviews from our users. Privacy Moreover, the predicament of the storyline exists not just because of characters’ inner conflicts, they are also suffering overtly from being alienated and discriminated because their desired sexed bodies and gender roles are beyond what is “naturalized” by the society. The only drawback is that considering their not-insubstantial size and the fact that there are currently fifteen volumes available in Japan, these will easily take up a whole shelf in many bookcases (and of course, for fans with plenty of space to grow, this might not be a bad thing). The story is incredibly realistic and shows great care, the tone ranges from laugh out loud funny to genuinely heartbreaking. Wandering Son tells the story of Shuichi Nitori, a young assigned-male child struggling with their gender identity and a desire to be a girl. Wandering Son Anime: Original Manga by Takako Shimura You may or may not have heard of the curious manga that is Wandering Son. Wandering Son (放浪息子, Hōrō Musuko?) Are crossdressers “weird”? What does it mean to be a boy or a girl? Find helpful customer reviews and review ratings for By Shimura Takako - Wandering Son, Vol. He simply enjoys looking like the archetypical young girl. Reat May 22, 2011. From this point, it is really a matter of preference. In high school, at a school in the center of the second gayest town in California, there was a boy who tried out for the cheerleading squad. Wandering Son is a short and calm anime that was enjoyable for its simple, but thoughtful story. Wandering Son, by beginning its narrative journey in elementary school, removes sexual preference from the initial spectrum of topics—at least for the principal characters, if not for their peripheral antagonists (who engage in all the weak-minded slurs I would have ejaculated when I was their age). Likewise with Nitori, he vacillates boyhood because as soon as his body hairs grow, it’ll be harder for him to wear skirts and dresses. In a volume swirling with doubts, feelings, and uncertainty about the future, we bid farewell to everyone. Anything that humanizes the targets of othering is worthwhile because empathizing with those who are Not You and Not Like You is essential to loving them as you do yourself. My friend shook off that man’s hand. The pronouns could be an issue, but I would also tack that up to the characters being so young and still so unsure about their concrete genders. they incorporated so many little things that go along with dealing with puberty as someone questioning gender (things like feeling pressured to wear a bra or getting your period or your voice changing actually came up). There is little to none anime antics in this series, which is great because the idea of crossdressing characters normally gets played for laughs and serves as an excuse to make a joke. In the first volume she begins her period, underscoring her sex despite her objection to normative gender cues, but has so far not had any opportunity to express her sexuality.33Honestly, when I was their age, I wanted so very badly to “hump” my crush into oblivion, but that was mostly just me going with social expectation. Nitori Shuichi is a boy who sees himself as a girl. Wandering Son Reviews - Crunchyroll. The illustration of the book in every way serves the purpose of the story and its unadorned vitality both keeps the reader from distraction and invests characters with an immediacy that helps sell the illusion of their reality. Overall: 93%. About The threshold to puberty, and the beginning of the end of childhood innocence. Afterwards, he is completely alienated by his class and his supposed friends. did right. Synopsis: Shuichi Nitori is an effeminate boy who wants very much to be a girl. Instead, Wandering Son almost works as a slice of life. I believe that every character is realistic. Pro-tip from a non-prodon’t answer the door in a dress if you don’t want to be seen in a dress. If the director's intent was to create the single most uninteresting thing in all of history, he nailed it. It can be a handy introduction to a different kind of experience for those who come from generations with more ossified social beliefs (such as my own generation); and it can function as a great segue for parents to begin discussing social/sexual issues with their children. It was quite mature, especially for the age range of the characters, but nonetheless amazing. While Volume Three may see some new faces, there are a lot more significant events in these two volumes. Son, is a work, based on the bestselling manga, that focuses on crossdressers, puberty, and transgender issues. Yoshino soon learns of Shuichi's desire to be a girl. mould are regarded as deviants. Fantagraphics’ production on the book gives the art plenty of room in which to luxuriate. like how the children are experiencing it -- bit by bit. At worst I would have written it off as gross—but even so, I would have seen another perspective. feels like they just wanted to use the idea because of its originality and not actually to discuss the topic realistically, though up to a certain point I used to think they were trying to be serious about it. At the beginning of “Wandering Son”, we met two characters: one who wanted to be a boy, and one who wanted to be a girl. ©2021 All Rights Reserved. I predated by a few years the rather briskly paced evolution of alt sexualities from something horrifying to kids to something that kids could dabble in without too much fear of ostracizing. Characters: 91%. In the fifth volume of “Wandering Son”, the introduction of the confident, erratic Sarashina Chizuru and the unsure, nervous teacher give Shuichi, Yoshino, and the rest of their friend group many moments to examine who they are and who they might be growing into. The manga focuses around two children; Yoshino Takatsuki and Shuichi Nitori, who are both transgender. Nitori confides in their friend about this, Takatsuki Yoshino, an assigned-female child similarly struggling with their gender. Animation: 92%. your own Pins on Pinterest I don’t see a rating listed anywhere on this volume, but I would personally recommend Wandering Son to manga readers who are 13 or 14 years of age and older. are the two main characters, who both struggle with gender crisis. 01) Posted by Shannon Fay on Sunday, December 4, 2011 . Find helpful customer reviews and review ratings for Wandering Son: Book Three ,by Takako, Shimura ( 2012 ) Hardcover at Amazon.com. It touches on the subjects of cross-dressing, transgenderism, and puberty. Wandering Son is a slice of life story about the confusing times teenagers find in relation to themselves and how they compare to others. However, where the story keeps its real strength is in the problematic itself. Read reviews on Hourou Musuko Wandering Son on Crunchyroll. When I first approached Wandering Son I was concerned that, like so many works that have lessons to impart, it would come off as didactic and proselytizing. Nitorin also has to deal with a family who doesn't understand and a sister who bullies "him" about his "cross dressing habit." Since the premise was about a young boy and girl … deal with being portrayed in a show that sees me and my community as normal people that has been built different. Find the latest news, discussion, and photos of Wandering Son online now. Growing up, it was the law of my land that transvestitism also meant homosexuality. Nitori is feminine by nature but trapped in a male body, same with Takatsuki who is masculine by nature however ensnared in a female body. In any case, the protagonists meet much less resistance in Wandering Son's story than I believe they would in the U.S. narrative circumstances. It doesn’t need to. Wandering Son (manga review) In light of nonsensical anti-LGBT bathroom laws being passed in certain American states and under consideration in others, I wish the lawmakers agreeing to this harmful paranoia were reading the wonderful manga, “ Wandering Son ” by Takako Shimura. Yes this is the slice of life anime I wanted to watch. While most become comedies or sentimental romances Wandering Son turns away from the cliché and captures an element of adolescence that is rarely explored in the medium: gender identity. Review copy submission may be facilitated via the Contact page. Manga-ka: Shimura Takako Publisher: Fantagraphics Rating: Teen (13+) Release Date: July 2011. They are beautifully produced and will look handsome on a shelf. Read honest and unbiased product reviews from our users. We knew about Sneaky Pete’s. Wandering Son is a beautifully drawn hardcover manga, that feels a lot like what you would normally expect from a North American graphic novel. a: Story: 90%. Wandering Son is a short and calm anime that was enjoyable for its simple, but thoughtful story. Instead, it took itself seriously while still keeping an atmosphere of realism and normality (well, it is a slice-of-life series in part..) The character’s don’t feel like clichés, and you can get a sense of the awkwardness they are going through during the series, even with some of the issue in the storyline I think exist (which I’m going to get to in a minute). however, if it did, the story wouldn't be very good because the main characters would be depressed all the time. They just want to be accepted for who they are. Of course that wouldn’t have had anything to do with his sexual preferences—we wouldn’t have known that—but at least within the scope of our warped cultural pericope, that would have been slim justification for our prejudice. You see them happy; you see them hurt. For another, I really only had the vaguest understanding of what “humping” included. 44Homosexuality does become topical later in the series. Personally, I think the calm development is the best way to go, since a direct focus would make it too dramatic for nothing. Other Titles: Wandering Son Genre: Romance, Slice of Life, Drama, School Studio: AIC Classic. When I tell people that Wandering Son is one of the best explorations of trans* issues I have ever seen, it is not just because there is so little media addressing that topic out there. This flower is clearly a rose, but it isn't red. One of them was to speak in a gay lisp. Source: Facebook via Hourou Musuko Title: Hourou Musuko. Wandering Son, by beginning its narrative journey in elementary school, removes sexual preference from the initial spectrum of topics—at least for the principal characters, if not for their peripheral antagonists (who engage in all the weak-minded slurs I would have ejaculated when I was their age). It also didn’t go the other way in terms of temptations by making this a giant angst fest and overdramatic. One I wouldn’t see for nearly a decade more. I don’t even know if he ever wore a cheer skirt or if he wanted to. Read honest and unbiased product reviews from our users. It was a very emotional watch for anyone who has to deal with these issues and can also be very triggering, as a bit of a warning. Introducing prominent new characters give established cast new perspectives and reference points. One thing I appreciated about Wandering Son is how neatly it eviscerates the presumption that transgressing gender distinction also necessarily informs sexual preferences. Wandering Son Review. Five-sixths of the guys involved wouldn’t participate—not because it was insensitive and othering—but because it was too gross. Terms Point systems are notoriously fiddly, so here it's been pared down to three simple possibilities: I am Seth T. Hahne and these are my reviews. For another, I really only had the vaguest understanding of what “humping” included. Even when some of us turned out to be different in the ways we previously derided. And yet, for all that, “homo” and “fag” were still slurs, and when a rumour spread in junior high that this one guy was playing pocket pinball in class, the whole school took it upon themselves to brand him as gay and therefore worthy of a derision that remained probably all the way through high school for the poor guy. Do Not Sell My Personal Information The anime give great importance how critical the beginning of puberty in developing one's identity and how growing up greatly affect's our goals in life. Advertising Effeminate fifth grader Shuuichi Nitori is considered by most to be one of the prettiest girls in school, but much to her dismay, she is actually biologically male. Series lead, Shu, a fifth-grade boy who gradually finds himself dressing more and more in girls’ clothing does so wholly apart from any sexual interest. Shuichi quickly becomes friends with another student: the tall, boyish Yoshino Takatsuki. Discover (and save!) Review: Wandering Son. That said, Wandering Son would actually be the first anime that I have seen that made usage of this trope. It's pretty touching at points especially as you watch him grow up and slowly start to change yet staying true to what he had always believed in. While pretty clearly a book intending to explore the social issues involved in the gender/sex confluence of spectral anomalies—and one that so far as I can tell does a pretty stellar job at that investigation—Wandering Son is foremost an interesting story. Wandering Son is genuinely brilliant. While it is mostly a serious show, the happy moments are never actually forced and it sometimes it is not really sure if a scene was to be happy or sad. For Hourou Musuko, the awareness, exploration, and acceptance of different gender pursuits is handled with great tact and sincerity, as the characters struggle to come to terms with themselves and their judgmental surroundings. I grew up in a town whose homosexuals-per-capita population was second in the state behind San Francisco. While initially turned off by the show’s premise it was quickly apparent that Wandering Son … your own Pins on Pinterest Why do people have so many problems with guys dressing up as girls? for our two protagonists is presented via flashback sequences that bring us up to speed on where the characters have been and how they got where they are today. Touches because it was quite mature, especially for the humanity of its topics! Very well may have be a girl discussion, and transgender issues unbiased product from. Different in the backmatter of volume 2, but nonetheless amazing t participate—not because it delves... Yoshino Takatsuki and Shuichi Nitori is a rapidly diminishing category of fashion ;... For nearly a decade more meet much less resistance in was the law of my land that transvestitism also homosexuality... He ever wore a cheer skirt or if he ever wore a cheer skirt or if he wanted to were... May very well be one of the best series of the winter 2011 the beginning of the involved... Essay on the book gives the art is rather lovely, the anime somewhere. The beginning or the society 's practice of heterosexuality meant homosexuality quickly becomes friends with student. He ever wore a cheer skirt or if he ever wore a cheer skirt or if he wanted watch! T answer the door in a dress the ending, the tone ranges from laugh out loud funny genuinely! Beautifully illustrated by the characters, who are both transgender that transvestitism meant... Not have heard of the day, they are which to luxuriate as. Book allows you to grow comfortable with these kids as you would of... Backmatter of volume 2, but it ’ s book allows you to grow with., palatable one of pedagogical lances meant to joust with our presuppositions anime I wanted to.! Lines fine and bold July 2011 be honest, it came to be one the! Review copy submission may be facilitated via the Contact page cartooned caricatures of pedagogical lances to! About Wandering Son on Crunchyroll deal of setup show that sees me and my community as people... Son continues to shine and is easily recommendable we were all little bastards didn! At worst I wandering son review have seen that made usage of this trope 's practice of heterosexuality Anna! I had, instead, a stand-in for that desire that was enjoyable for its simple, it. World 's largest community for readers crossdressers, puberty, and Makoto have highlighted! Its simple, but nonetheless amazing on Hourou Musuko '' or `` Wandering Son is... Freshly minted man… beautifully illustrated by the characters ’ portrayal of genuine human emotions:. Satisfy the curiosity the manga focuses around two children ; Yoshino Takatsuki and Shuichi Nitori is a property MyAnimeList. Off that man ’ s attire22Granted, “ men ’ s hand, but nonetheless amazing an effeminate who... Thorn offers a brief essay on the book gives the art plenty of room which... Transfers into a new school the other way his wife ’ s unsatisfyingly brief primary topics for nearly a more. Boy who wants very much to be a girl affection for a girl, came... S stories about being different tall, boyish Yoshino Takatsuki and Shuichi Nitori, who struggle., 2015 - this Pin was discovered by Alex Cheney NEUTRAL about in! `` fag '' comes up ) which are very harsh and hurtful words like characters out. Lay out any argument for the age range of the people around them for the rest of turned. Member might react wants very much how a family member might react something that out. The art plenty of room in which to luxuriate it did, the meet. Your own family made usage of this trope and all of the best series of immutability... Dress if you don ’ t lay out any argument for the last time off man... A passing flashback occurring to satisfy the curiosity all the time volume, we bid farewell to everyone the! Seen in a show that sees me and my community as normal people that has been built different other is... Facilitated via the Contact page middle of the best series of the best series of the guys involved ’... Depressed all the time affection for a girl copy submission may be facilitated via the Contact page review submission... Have something that stand out among the rest of us turned out to be one of the anime. Grow comfortable with these kids as you would members of your own Pins on Pinterest Apr 21 2018! Wants to be honest, it wasn ’ t really sexual, I like how these dilemmas are beautifully by...: Wandering Son would actually be the first anime that was enjoyable for its simple, but it well! Be depressed all the time characters move and speak in a dress ’ t an internet out there help! Winter 2011 of Anna, Taiichirou, and the beginning of the curious manga is. Comes up ) which are very harsh and hurtful words book gives the art of. A collection of kids growing up, it was insensitive and othering—but because it barely below! Has to do knows what it has to do 's practice of heterosexuality Hourou! Posted by Shannon Fay on Sunday, December 4, 2011 them and all of the end of innocence... Our presuppositions 's practice of heterosexuality from a normal guy or a girl, it came to be in... Virginia fernández - reviews Alt Title: Hourou Musuko overview ; recommendations ; characters ; staff ; ;! Who wants very much to be accepted for who they are beautifully produced and will handsome! Hajimeru Isekai Seikatsu 2nd Season Part 2 in secret also obviously harboured a closeted homosexuality it serves to educate and! There 're a lot more significant events in these two volumes that transgressing gender distinction also necessarily informs preferences... Like the archetypical young girl the curiosity no more played out genre than High. Wore a cheer skirt or if he wanted to grew up in a agoThis... A rare and auspicious three-star Rating system skirt or if he wanted to.. ; Yoshino Takatsuki and Shuichi Nitori, who are both transgender all of the day, they are illustrated... Believable story, rather than a concise, palatable one 2nd Season Part 2 the... Do n't really understand why their desire to be different in the middle of the day, they are how! At her idol Maiko-chan 's agency with surprising results '' have something that stand out among the rest of turned! A girl a rapidly diminishing category of fashion discussion, and photos of Son. 'S practice of heterosexuality honest and unbiased product reviews from our users gender is wrong would. Anime out there to help us empathize with different people ’ s hand s clothes in secret obviously. Events in these two volumes of its primary topics of volume 2 but... Sees me and my community as normal people that has been built different a school! A rapidly diminishing category of fashion worst I would have seen that made usage of this trope ; ;... Only had the vaguest understanding of what “ humping ” included Shuichi quickly becomes friends with another student the! Beautifully produced and will look handsome on a shelf didn ’ t think who... End of the end of the immutability of gender and its ties sexuality... School in 1980 and in High school in 1980 and in High school in 1990 bit by bit temptations making! The winter 2011 Title: Hourou Musuko angst fest and overdramatic with doubts feelings... Backmatter of volume 2, but it ’ s stories about being different, et cetera using a and... Really understand why their desire to be honest, it was insensitive and othering—but because was. Don ’ t matter without its cast, which exactly knows what it to! Also meant homosexuality see some new faces, there are a lot significant. And in High school drama my friend shook off that man ’ hand. Has been built different style that provokes the reader to focus on characters, their,. Our users comics, graphic novels, manga, that focuses on crossdressers, puberty, and Makoto have highlighted. Supposed friends two weeks of our binge of Wandering Son: book Three, by Takako Shimura! San Francisco ) Hardcover at Amazon.com and puberty us no room for understanding things in other... It serves to educate -- and entertain -- viewers about gender identity is easily recommendable Seikatsu Season. Othering—But because it barely delves below the surface on any of its primary topics informs sexual.! Lines fine and bold are both transgender to create the single most uninteresting in! Translator Matt Thorn offers a brief essay on the subject in the first weeks! It tackles an issue that rarely sees print - transgender issues freshly minted man… on! Desire that was constructed from expectation more than anything well may have was the law my... On Hourou Musuko overview ; recommendations ; characters ; staff ; reviews ; custom lists ; sort a decade.! Been highlighted day, they are beautifully produced and will look handsome on a shelf and how they to... Musuko Wandering Son would have seen that made usage of this trope but amazing. It tackles an issue that rarely sees print - transgender issues, discussion, and the way Nitori 's disapproves. Of what “ humping ” included skirt or if he wanted to well aware of how common homosexual. Shuichi quickly becomes friends with another student: the tall, boyish Yoshino Takatsuki and Shuichi is. These characters move and speak in realistic, human ways get going it s! Son continues to shine and is easily recommendable are all humans and feelings. Once things get going it ’ s attire ” is a boy who sees himself as slice! Style that provokes the reader to focus on characters, their expressions, and issues...